| 1962-63 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Gerry Emond | Allan French | Ron Allain |
| North Bay Trappers | Espanola Eagles | Espanola Eagles |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Reg Rathwell | Jim Currie | Tony Esposito |
| North Bay Trappers | Espanola Eagles | Soo Greyhounds |
| COACH | ||
| Red McCarthy | ||
| Espanola Eagles | ||
| 1963-64 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Wayne Maki | Bob Leduc | Brian Dooling |
| Soo Greyhounds | Sudbury Wolves | North Bay Trappers |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Sheldon Kannegeiser | Wayne McQuaig | Gaye Cooley |
| North Bay Trappers | Sudbury Wolves | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | ||
| Howie Parker | ||
| North Bay Trappers | ||
| 1964-65 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Mike Buba | Marty Reynolds | Randy Prior |
| Sudbury Wolves | North Bay Trappers | North Bay Trappers |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Sheldon Kannegeiser | Archie Orazietti | Bill White |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds |
| COACH | ||
| Howie Parker/Walter Dubas | ||
| North Bay/Soo Greyhounds | ||
| 1965-66 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Ike Piche | Marty Reynolds | Randy Prior |
| Espanola Eagles | North Bay Trappers | North Bay Trappers |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Ron Burman | Roger Wilson | Andre Lalande |
| North Bay Trappers | Sudbury Wolves | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | ||
| Red McCarthy | ||
| Espanola Eagles | ||
| 1966-67 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Bob Tombari | Bob Smith | Mario Francella |
| Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Ab Demarco Jr. | Rich Pagnutti | Bill White |
| North Bay Trappers | Sudbury Wolves | Soo Greyhounds |
| COACH | ||
| Walter Dubas | ||
| Soo Greyhounds | ||
| 1967-68 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Gord Gallagher | Lloyd Bentley | Don Grierson |
| Espanola Eagles | Soo Greyhounds | North Bay Trappers |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Ron Byrne | Don McCulloch | Don Muio |
| Sudbury Wolves | Espanola Eagles | Soo Greyhounds |
| COACH | ||
| Walter Dubas | ||
| Soo Greyhounds | ||
| 1968-69 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Bill Buba | Rob Guzzo | Brian Lafleur |
| Sudbury Wolves | Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Denis Chevrier | Bill Slewidge | Carl Piehl |
| Garson-Falconbridge Native Sons | Soo Greyhounds | Garson-Falconbridge Native Sons |
| COACH | ||
| Walter Dubas | ||
| Soo Greyhounds | ||
| 1969-70 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Ed Bumbacco | Julio Francella | Al Blanchard |
| Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds | Sudbury Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Bill Slewidge | Dave Fortier | Bob Dupuis |
| Soo Greyhounds | Chelmsford Canadians | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | ||
| Marcel Clements | ||
| Sudbury Wolves | ||
| 1970-71 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| John Campbell/Bob Sykes | Al Hamill | Al Blanchard |
| Soo Greyhounds/Sudbury | Sudbury Wolves | Sudbury Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Bill Slewidge | D'Arcy Keating | Bob Dupuis |
| Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | ||
| Ab Carricato/Dan O'Connor | ||
| Soo Greyhounds/Chelmsford | ||
| 1971-72 ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| John Simon | Mike Zuke | Jim Mayer |
| Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds | Soo Greyhounds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Mike Penasse | John Flesch | Pat Tims |
| North Bay Trappers | Sudbury Wolves | Sudbury Wolves |
| COACH | ||
| Ab Carricato | ||
| Soo Greyhounds | ||
