| 1990-91 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Rick McKenzie | Gord Geisler | Brian Stagg |
| Sudbury Cubs | Powassan Passports | Powassan Passports |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Mike Lebouef | Randy Koski | Blair Molto |
| Powassan Passports | Sudbury Cubs | Sudbury Cubs |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Guy Blanchard | Guy Blanchard | Chris May |
| Powassan Passports | Powassan Passports | Powassan Passports |
| 1990-91 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| George Burton | Willie McGarvey | Armin Taege |
| Sudbury Cubs | Sudbury Cubs | Elliot Lake vikings |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Danny Lavallee | Mike Longo | Rock Chatel |
| Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Rayside Balfour Canadians | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Bob Giroux | Oscar Clouthier | Tony Rivait |
| Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Rayside Balfour Canadians | Sudbury Cubs |
| 1991-92 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Mike Dore | Trevor Tremblay | Jon Stos |
| Rayside Balfour Canadians | Rayside Balfour Canadians | Rayside Balfour Canadians |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Dennis Gosselin | George Wilson | Peter Papadogiannis |
| Rayside Balfour Canadians | Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Guy Blanchard | Guy Blanchard | Jacques Charette |
| Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales |
| 1991-92 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Bart Hurley | Steve Sullivan | Dean Cull |
| Sudbury Cubs | Timmins Golden Bears | Rayside Balfour Canadians |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Mike Longo | Peter Johansson | Jason Prior |
| Rayside Balfour Canadians | Timmins Golden Bears | Timmins Golden Bears |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Kenn Sullivan | Bob Giroux | Tom Stagg |
| Timmins Golden Bears | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Powassan Hawks |
| 1992-93 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Mike Dore | Gord Geisler | Derek McNair |
| Rayside Balfour Canadians | Powassan Hawks | Timmins Golden Bears |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Derek Chenette | Peter Johansson | Jason Prior |
| Powassan Hawks | Timmins Golden Bears | Powassan Hawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Kenn Sullivan | Jack Dempsey | Bob Nadeau |
| Timmins Golden Bears | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Timmins Golden Bears |
| 1992-93 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Jonas Rudberg | Dean Roach | Dan Despatie |
| Timmins Golden Bears | Timmins Golden Bears | Nickel Centre Cubs |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Kevin Culhane | Derek McChesney | Jason Hall |
| Espanola Eagles | Powassan Hawks | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Chris Puskas | Guy Blanchard | Tom Stagg |
| Rayside Balfour Canadians | Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks |
| 1993-94 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Bruno Vallieres | Jamie Spadafora | Jean Guy Trudel |
| Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Espanola Eagles | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Nicolas Cossette | Derek McChesne | Jason Prior |
| Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Guy Blanchard | Guy Blanchard | Michel Marcoux |
| Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales |
| 1993-94 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brent Dube | Sylvain Murray | Dan Despatie |
| Powassan Hawks | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Espanola Eagles |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Ray Giroux | Laine Schubert | Jason Larouche |
| Powassan Hawks | Powassan Hawks | Timmins Golden Bears |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Gord Ouimet | Mark Capeless | Bob Nadeau |
| Elliot Lake Vikings | Elliot Lake vikings | Timmins Golden Bears |
| 1994-95 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Falcioni | Andrew Bain | Guy Labelle |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Timmins Golden Bears | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Mike Seguin | Nicolas Cossette | Mitch Perreault |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Kenn Sullivan | Iain Mills | Al Cannon |
| Timmins Golden Bears | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Elliot Lake Vikings |
| 1994-95 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Mike Roy | Ed Lawrence | Ryan McCormack |
| Timmins Golden Bears | Parry Sound shamrocks | Parry Sound Shamrocks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Terry Noel | Richard Vachon | Jason Larouche |
| Elliot Lake Vikings | Timmins Golden Bears | Timmins Golden Bears |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Guy Blanchard | Guy Blanchard | Tom Stagg |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| 1995-96 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Jeff Boulanger | Sylvain Murray | Ian MacDougall |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Derek Lahnalampi | Sheldon Cappadocia | Darryl White |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Jeff Brick | Gary Delorme | Bob Nadeau |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Timmins Golden Bears |
| 1995-96 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Falcioni | Craig Brown | Stephane Lefebvre |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Timmins Golden Bears |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Chad Grandy | Richard Vachon | Mike Watson |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Timmins Golden Bears | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Guy Blanchard | Jack Dempsey | Al Cannon |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rouyn-Noranda Capitales | Elliot Lake Vikings |
| 1996-97 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Falcioni | Darryl Moxam | Bruce Paris |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Darren Schmidt | Sheldon Cappadocia | Mike Watson |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Ken MacKenzie | Barry Tabobondung | Bryan Emery |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Parry Sound Shamrocks |
| 1996-97 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Marc Bouffard | Shawn Denomme | Marc Trottier |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Serge Dube | Sean McTernan | Brian Harrison |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Parry Sound Shamrocks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Barry Tabobondung | Guy Blanchard | Tom Stagg |
| Parry Sound Shamrocks | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| 1997-98 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Falcioni | Martin Birch | Todd Crane |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Timmins Golden Bears | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Jamie Vossen | Serge Dube | Jarrett Rose |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Ken MacKenzie | Gary Delorme | Michel "Jinks" Desormeau |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| 1997-98 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Marc Bouffard | Darren Debrie | Mike Breadmore |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Alex Tomaras | Matt Hodges | Ted Brethour |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Parry Sound Shamrocks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Ron Guy | Paul Borneman | Bryan Emery |
| Parry Sound Shamrocks | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Parry Sound Shamrocks |
| 1998-99 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Chris Shamess | Darren Debrie | Marc Bouffard |
| Espanola Eagles | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Stu Bisset | Troy Turyk | Luc Lamothe |
| Elliot Lake Ice | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Ron Guy | Guy Blanchard | Dwight Beer |
| Parry Sound Shamrocks | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Espanola Eagles |
| 1998-99 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Terry Chikoski | Mike Hull | Todd Crane |
| Parry Sound Shamrocks | Elliot Lake Ice | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Tyson Cross | Chris Mei | Terry Joss |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Parry Sound Shamrocks | Elliot Lake Ice |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Frank Porco | Iain Mills | |
| Elliot Lake Ice | Espanola Eagles | |
| 1999-00 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Trevor Swain | Mike Comeau | Luc Messier |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Troy Turyk | Serge Dube | Frank Novello |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Ken MacKenzie | Bob Frappier | Roy MacDonald |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Espanola Screaming Eagles |
| 1999-00 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Steve Fillion | Patrick Jarrett | Matt Shank |
| Iroquois Falls Jr Eskis | Soo Thunderbirds | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Jeff Cochrane | Alex Tomaras | Sebastien Laplante |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Bart Jarrett | Mel Mousseau | Fordy Varcoe |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Iroquois Falls Jr Eskis | Soo Thunderbirds |
