| 2000-01 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Ryan Corcoran | Justin Carre | Fred Coccimiglio |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Jason Michelutti | Jeff Cochrane | Josh Siembida |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds | Espanola Screaming Eagles |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Jim Capy | Sam Biasucci | Fordy Varcoe |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| 2000-01 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Barnhardt | David Borrelli | Nevin Patterson |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Todd Rayne | Bruce Winn | Frank Novello |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Wayne Goudreau | Guy Blanchard | Bob Davidson |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Blind River Beavers |
| 2001-02 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| T.J.Warkus | David Borrelli | Matt Shank |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds | Sudbury Northern Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Bruce Winn | Jason Michelutti | Luke Oshell |
| Sturgeon Falls Lynx | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Sturgeon Falls Lynx |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Don Lees Jr. | Bob Davidson |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Blind River Beavers | Blind River Beavers |
| 2001-02 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| John-Michel Rizk/Josh Thompson | Mike Vaillancourt | Derek MacKay |
| Sudbury/Soo T-Birds | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Robin Robichaud | Josh Chase | Adam Hanna |
| Iroquois Falls Jr. Eskis | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Wayne Goudreau/Ken MacKenzie | Mark Seidel | Roy MacDonald |
| Sudbury/Rayside Balfour | Espanola Screaming Eagles | Espanola Screaming Eagles |
| 2002-03 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Joey Coccimiglio | Jeff Rainville | Sylvain Houle |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Matt Laakso | Bruce Winn | Danny Battochio |
| Espanola Screaming Eagles | North Bay Skyhawks | Sudbury Northern Wolves |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Don Lees Jr. | Mike Desormeaux |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Blind River Beavers | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| 2002-03 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Wally Prawdzik | Matt Tremblay | J.P. Pauly |
| Rayside Balfour Sabrecats | Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Barabus Birkeland | Jeff Shaw | Martin Perreault |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Bart Jarrett | Guy Blanchard | Gerry Liscum |
| Blind River Beavers | North Bay Skyhawks | Soo Thunderbirds |
| 2003-04 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brian McGarry | Matt Tremblay | Tyer Eadie |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Abitibi Eskimos | North Bay Skyhawks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Ryan MacKay | Bruce Winn | Tony Stoehr |
| Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks | Northern Michigan Black Bears |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Paul Gagne | Gerry Liscum |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Thunderbirds |
| 2003-04 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brent Assinewai | Thomas Laplante | Jesse Graham |
| Manitoulin Wild | Blind River Beavers | Sudbury Northern Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Chuck Battah | John Nogatch | Martin Perreault |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Northern Michigan Black Bears | North Bay Skyhawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Stephane Souliere | Charly Murray | Bruce Renwick |
| Manitoulin Wild | Northern Michigan Black Bears | Abitibi Eskimos |
| 2004-05 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brian McGarry | Thomas Laplante | Matt Dias |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Kyle Hope | Josh Merson | Steve Hamel |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | North Bay Skyhawks | Abitibi Eskimos |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Toots Kovacs | Al Jones | Tom Stagg/Billy Syms |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay/Soo Thunderbirds |
| 2004-05 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Adam Chircoski | Matt Caria | Tyler Perry |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| John Bogatch | Nick Torresan | Mike Maulucci |
| Northern Michigan Black Bears | Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Gerry Lortie | Don Lees Jr | Mike Desormeaux |
| Northern Michigan Black Bears | Blind River Beavers | Rayside Balfour Sabrecats |
| 2005-06 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brendan Biedermann | Brian McGarry | Nick Heins |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Sudbury Northern Wolves | Sudbury Northern Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Rob Bonhomme | Quinn Waller | Paul Pidutti |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | North Bay Skyhawks | Sudbury Northern Wolves |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Darryl Moxam | Barry McCrory | Bruce Renwick |
| Sudbury Northern Wolves | Sudbury Northern Wolves | Abitibi Eskimos |
| 2005-06 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Mike McMillan | Ryan Maunu | Nick Kulas |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Nick Jelitto | Alex Ward | Billy Stone |
| Blind River Beavers | North Bay Skyhawks | Manitoulin Islanders |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Toots Kovacs | Todd Stencill | Donna Robinson/Nikola Gray |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Manitoulin Islanders | Northern Michigan Black Bears |
| 2006-07 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brendan Biedermann | Dan Dube | Jean-Francois Houle |
| Sudbury Jr. Wolves | Abitibi Eskimos | Sudbury Jr. Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Scott Lavigne | Mitch Champagne | Brennan Poderzay |
| Sudbury Jr. Wolves | Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Indians |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Todd Stencill | Don Lees Jr. | Billy Syms |
| Blind River Beavers | Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds |
| 2006-07 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Anthony Libonati | Shawn Farley | Nick Kulas |
| Blind River Beavers | Soo Indians | North Bay Skyhawks |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Brad Norkum | Andre Gauvin | Miles Williams |
| North Bay Skyhawks | Blind River Beavers | Abitibi Eskimos |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Barry Parsons | Al Jones | Rick Stanton |
| Manitoulin Islanders | Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Skyhawks |
| 2007-08 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Jeremie Dorval | Dustin Fummerton | Russell Morin |
| Abitibi Eskimos | North Bay Skyhawks | Abitibi Eskimos |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Chris Pontes | Ben Davey | Jake Rosenthal |
| Sudbury Kal Tire Jr. Wolves | Soo Thunderbirds | Blind River Beavers |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Al Jones | Mike-Jon Peltier |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Thunderbirds | Manitoulin Islanders |
| 2007-08 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brendan Biedermann | Brandon Ingraham | Nick Minardi |
| Sudbury Kal Tire Jr. Wolves | Manitoulin Islanders | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Brad Norkum | Matt Bell | Travis O'Brien |
| North Bay Skyhawks | Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Pat Carricato | Paul Gagne | James Judd |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos |
| 2008-09 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Solomon McCann | Dustin Fummerton | Nick Minardi |
| North Bay Skyhawks | North Bay Skyhawks | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Kyle Radigan | Drew Otto | Ryan Dube |
| North Bay Skyhawks | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Pat Carricato | Oscar Clouthier | Rejean Gagnon |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves |
| 2008-09 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Trevor McNutt | Jerry Petingalo | Chris Kangas |
| North Bay Skyhawks | Soo Thunderbirds | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Benoit Gauthier | Chris Pontes | Jeff Michael |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves | North Bay Skyhawks |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Theriault | Larry Roy | Robert Gauthier |
| Soo Eagles | Manitoulin Islanders | Blind River Beavers |
| 2009-10 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Joshua Clancy | Felix Boutin | Marc-Alain Begin |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Josh McCully | Drew Otto | Eddie Davey |
| Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds | Abitibi Eskimos |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Paul Gagne | John Matheson |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos | Manitoulin Islanders |
| 2009-10 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Chad Richard | Brett Findlay | Tyler Evoy |
| Blind River Beavers | Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Sacha Guimond | Bronson Kovacs | John Kleinhans |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Eagles |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Jim Capy | Al Jones | Guy Boisvert |
| Blind River Beavers | Soo Thunderbirds | Abitibi Eskimos |
