| 2013-14 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Brady Clouthier | Gavin Burbach | Brennen Dubchak |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Soo Thunderbirds | Espanola Rivermen |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Jeremy Picard-Fiset | Tyler Jones | Joel Horodziejczyk |
| Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Jordan Smith | Kevin Cain | Carla Vine |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | Kirkland Lake Gold Miners |
| 2013-14 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Corbin Bean | Steven Babin | Brett Wagner |
| Espanola Rivermen | Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | Elliot Lake Bobcats |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Bradley Bell | Max Glashauser | Evan Cormier |
| Sudbury Nickel Barons | Elliot Lake Bobcats | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Marc Lafleur | Oscar Clouthier | Lise Parise |
| Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | Sudbury Nickel Barons | Sudbury Nickel Barons |
| 2012-13 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Sebastien Leroux | Darcy Haines | Tait Seguin |
| Sudbury Nickel Barons | Sudbury Nickel Barons | North Bay Trappers |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Adam Newkirk | Jeremy Picard-Fiset | Greg Dodds |
| Blind River Beavers | Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | North Bay Trappers |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Marc Lafleur | Rusty Joncas | Mario Laino |
| Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | Blind River Beavers | Sudbury Nickel Barons |
| 2012-13 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Darcy Casola | Brandon Janke | Brandon Warmington |
| Soo Thunderbirds | North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Cole Klippenstein | Michael Caruso | Joel Horodziejczyk |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Dave Clancy | Jim Mackinnon | Carla Vine |
| Sudbury Nickel Barons | Kirkland Lake Gold Miners | Kirkland Lake Gold Miners |
| 2011-12 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Jordan Carroll | Jamie Haines | Mickey Sartoretto |
| Sudbury Kal Tire Cubs | Sudbury Kal Tire Cubs | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Cory Sellers | Corey Jackson | John Kleinhans |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Tom McCarthy | Kevin Cain | Jim Whalen |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds | Sudbury Kal Tire Wolves |
| 2011-12 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Matt Amadio | Greg Sartoretto | Marc Alain Begin |
| Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Thunderbirds | Abitibi Eskimos |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Djordie Leposavic | Derek Diaz | Ken Appleby |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Eagles | Kirkland Lake GoldMiners |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Paul Gagne | Paul Gagne | Roger Gagne |
| Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos | Abitibi Eskimos |
| 2010-11 FIRST ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Andre Leclair | Aaron Leonard | Jerry Petingalo |
| Temiscaming Royals | Soo Eagles | Soo Thunderbirds |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Derek Diaz | Joel Gagnon | Michael Doan |
| Soo Eagles | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves | Soo Thunderbirds |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Bruno Bragagnolo | Kevin Cain | Mario Laino |
| Soo Eagles | Soo Thunderbirds | Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves |
| 2010-11 SECOND ALL STAR TEAM | ||
| LEFT WING | CENTRE | RIGHT WING |
| Zach McGillis | Brian Nanne | Brian Depp |
| Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves | Soo Thunderbirds | Soo Eagles |
| DEFENCE | DEFENCE | GOALTENDER |
| Matt Weisensel | Matt Fuller | Matt Zawadzki |
| North Bay Trappers | Soo Thunderbirds | Temiscaming Royals |
| COACH | MANAGER | TRAINER |
| Bryan Verreault | Bruno Bragagnolo | Dennis Spencer |
| Sudbury Kal Tire Jr Wolves | Soo Eagles | North Bay Trappers |
